Posts

#014, Upanishads and Gita are true scriptures

Swami Vivekananda wrote to Shri Pramadadas Mitra on May 30, 1897: "... The Upanishads and the Gita are the true scriptures; Rama, Krishna, Buddha, Chaitanya, Nanak, Kabir, and so on are the true Avataras ..." In the same letter he mentions: "...It is in the books written by priests that madnesses like that of caste are to be found, and not in books revealed from God. Let the priests enjoy the fruits of their ancestors' achievement, while I follow the word of God, for my good lies there..." BLOGGER'S VIEWS Had Vivekananda read verses 43 and 44 of chapter 18 of Bhagavad Gita, he would have easily found that one of Gita's principal objects was to impose caste system and the duties entrusted to every caste. I quote them here with translation: MSY 43 s`auryam teejoo dhrutir daakshyam yuddhee ca api apalaayanam daanam iis`varabhaavas` ca kshatrakarma svabhaavajam MSY 44 krushi goorakshya vaan`ijyam vais`yakarma svabhaavajam paricaryaatmakam karma s`uudrasyaa...

#013, Bengal brings Asthma

Swami Vivekananda wrote to Ms. Christina Greenstidel from Belur Math on Sept. 2, 1901: "... Of course, Bengal brings Asthma now and then, but it is getting tame, and the terrible things--Bright's disease and diabetes have disappeared altogether." NOT GOING TO TRY THE BENGALEE MOUNTAINS ANY MORE "Within the last few months, I got two fits [of asthma] by going to two of the dampest hill stations in Bengal — Shillong and Darjeeling. I am not going to try the Bengalee mountains any more." Swamiji wrote to Ms. Christina Greenstidel from Belur Math on Sept. 7, 1901: "As on the one hand there is some risk of catching malaria in Belur this month. In Calcutta, on the other hand there is the danger of plague." BLOGGER'S VIEWs *Afraid of Bengalee plains *Afraid of Bengalee mountains *Afraid of Malaria, Plague, Asthma *Which disease Swamiji was not afraid of?

012 Christina ! Sacrificed a goat and burned a lot of fireworks

Image
Advaitic Monks (Monistic Monks) preaching Advaita Vedanta (Monistic Philosophy) are supposed to be DISTINCT from mendicant monks and ordinary householders. Advaitic Monkhood is based on "GnAna" or GnAna Yoga, i.e. Awareness, and the Path of Awareness. What is this awareness about? It is about the Unity or oneness of one's living soul (jIvAtma) and the Supreme God (paramAtma). They are not separate. Once, a person gets this knowledge, and implements it in his daily life, he will become a jIvan-mukta (a liberated person, while being still alive). This jIvan mukta can never think of , or boast of petty things like worship of idols, sacrificing goats to idols, lighting and exploding fireworks. This must be particularly true of a monk, who goes on trumpeting in the entire world that he is an Advaita Philosophy Preacher, and who wants to accept disciples from foreigners who do not know anything about Advaita philosophy. Swami Vivekananda wrote to Ms. Christina Greenst...

#189 I have manfully borne the terrific heat of my country

Swami Vivekananda wrote to Ms. Christina Greenstidel in June 1901:- "...I have manfully borne the terrific heat of my country in the plains, and now I am facing the deluging rains of my country. ..." BLOGGER'S VIEW * Manful in bearing the heat of India ? Didn't the 360 million Indians (population of India in those days) of his days endure it? Was Vivekananda an exception? *Swami always went in search of cool stations like Ooty, Mount Abu, Almora, Darjeeling, Murre, Dehradun, Almora, Switzerland etc. *Numerous examples are available for this cooling himself fanatism. *Today India's population is 1100 million. At least 1090 million bear the heat of India. They do not have Air conditioners or coolers or they do not live at hill stations.

#010, boiled cabbage and potatoes and boiled rice and boiled lentils, three times a day

Question: How a Sanyaasi living on Bhiksaas`ana (alms) conduct himself particularly in his eating and other habits? During his second stay in US, Swami Vivekananda wrote to Mr. E.T. Sturdy one of his hosts in England during his first visit. Mr. Sturdy was a Sanskrit scholar. It appears that Vivekananda and Mr. Sturdy did some joint collaborative work in writing and publishing books. We can find from Vivekananda's letter that Mr. Sturdy took Vivekananda to his home as a guest and got him served by his wife meals three times a day. Thereafter, Vivekananda seems to have moved to a Hotel Room with the help of Miss Muller. When Vivekananda visited England and US second time in 1899, some misunderstandings seem to have developed between Mr. Sturdy and Vivekananda and Miss Muller and Vivekananda. According to Swami Vivekananda's letter of Nov. 1899 addressed to Mr. Sturdy, it is a reply addressed to the later for expressing a view about luxuries provided to Vivekananda durin...

#009 , RAMANUJA, SHANKARA ETC. ARE MERE PUNDITS

Swami Vivekananda wrote to Shri Pramada Das Mitra, on May 30, 1897 from Almora. Ramanuja, Shankara etc., seem to have been mere Pundits with much narrowness of heart . Where is that love, that weeping heart at the sorrow of others? — Dry pedantry of the Pundit — and the feeling of only oneself getting to salvation hurry-scurry! BLOGGER'S VIEW * The story of "Kankadharastava" (According to his biographers) : Sankara was moved by the poverty of a woman, who has nothing to give him as 'alms', except a small gooseberry fruit. Sankara prayed Goddess Lakshmi singing 'Kanakadhara stavam' and there was a rain of gold gooseberries. *Sankara was an introvert. Vivekananda was an extrovert behind an introvert mask. *Vivekananda joined the bandwagon of 'Collecting donations for serving the poor', imitating the Christian Missionaries. *If we see the epicurean ways of Vivekananda (craving for flesh, ice creams, cool stations, couches, furniture, big people, ca...

#008, Alasinga! WHO TOLD YOU THAT I WANT SOCIAL REFORM?

Swamiji wrote to Shri Alasinga Mudaliar in the second half of 1895 from New York, USA: "Meddle not with social reform, for there cannot be any reform without spiritual reform first. Who told you that I want social reform? . Not I. ..." BLOGGER'S VIEW Do the Indian poor want spirit? What India needed was not only a independence but social , economic and political reforms. The phrase 'spiritual reform' is vague. Spirits fed on ale, beef, chicken, fish, pizzas, pork, steak and turtles etc, cannot easily bend to reforms. India of 1895 needed revolution. India of 2011 too needs it with equal desparation. This revolution need not be bloody. No wonder, the Vivekananda of 1895 didn't recognise the need for a social reform just as the crazy-converting missionaries of his time. The leaders of the Islam also do not recognise such need. It is because reforms hurt them.