#149, WHO IS THIS YOUNG MAN R_?

Swami Vivekananda wrote to Ms. S.E. Waldo, from Wimbledon on Oct. 8, 1896:

I know very little of the young man R—. He is a Bengali and can teach a little Sanskrit. You know my settled doctrine. I do not trust any one who has not conquered "lust and gold". You may try him in theoretical subjects, but keep him off from teaching Raja-Yoga — that is a dangerous game except for the regularly trained to play at. Of Saradananda, the blessing of the greatest Yogi of modern India is on him — and there is no danger. Why do you not begin to teach? . . . You have a thousand times more philosophy than this boy R—.


BLOGGER'S VIEW
1. It is not clear who this young man R__ is.
2. Why Swamiji is belittling him, particularly when Swamiji himself says that he knows very little about the young man?

3. Did Swamiji conquer "lust and gold"?
-- If he has conquered "gold", why should he beg foreigners few dollars per month, for his personal maintenance?
-- If he has conquered "lust", why should he ask Ms. Christina Greenstidel for her photos and get his nerves overtaxed by seeing them?

4. Is teaching Raja Yoga, a monopoly of the disciples of "the great Yogi of Modern India" (presumably Vivekananda refers to Shri Ramakrishna's disciples)?

5. Are the disciples of Shri Ramakrishna, REGULARLY TRAINED TO PLAY AT RAJA YOGA? What they were trained in the group sittings and after meals Bhajans in the Camps of Shri Ramakrishna?

6. Vivekananda asks Ms. Waldo to teach! How does Vivekananda know that Ms. Waldo is a teacher superior to the young man, about whom Vivekananda knows very little? If a lay woman Waldo can teach, why the young man versed in Sanskrit cannot teach?

7. How does Vivekananda know that Ms. Waldo has more philosophy than the young man?

8. Was Shri Ramakrishna trained in teaching Raja Yoga?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

239 Do the questions of beef eating - drinking and smoking by Vivekananda really matter?

Image
Ans: Yes. The questions of beef eating and alcohol consumption really matter, for "parama hamsas" (Great Swans) and UPLIFTERS-OF-NATIONS, like Swami Vivekananda. They do not matter for ordinary hoi pollois like you and me. Question: Thousands of Vivekananda devotees seem to hold a view: *Was Vivekananda not entitled to his quota of fun? *What was wrong in Vivekananda's eating beef? *What was wrong in Vivekananda's consuming alcohol? *What was wrong in Vivekananda's smoking cigars? ybrao-a-donkey's humble comments. वैबीराव एक गधे के विनम्र राय వైబీరావ్ గాడిద వినమ్ర నివేదన. I shall not impose my views on you. ANSWERS: I am not here to pass any value judgements on Vivekananda's character or lifestyle. My objects here are to find out facts and examine how they differ from the generally held views of millions of Indians who worship him, reading the literature published by the Managers of his Cult. These things have now become contextually important...
Read more

108, There was nothing ... I am afraid

Image
Ms. Henrietta Muller was a major contributor to the purchase of the land for the Belur Math. On 15th May 1899, the American Newspaper Nagautuck Daily News published an item quoting a Mumbai newspaper her as saying that she is face to face with the unavoidable conclusion that it is utterly rotten and corrupt from beginning to end and full of danger to the unhappy people who place their faith in it. Ms. Henrietta Muller was a major contributor to the purchase of the land for the Belur Math. On 15th May 1899, the American Newspaper Nagautuck Daily News published an item quoting a Mumbai newspaper her as saying that she is face to face with the unavoidable conclusion that it is utterly rotten and corrupt from beginning to end and full of danger to the unhappy people who place their faith in it. In this connection, pl see review #65 by clicking the label #65 or the following link: http://vivekanandayb.blogspot.com/search/label/%23065 . The report of the Mumbai Newspaper is not trace...
Read more